Below, find the annual list produced by Metacritic that reflects an aggregation of over 300 "Top 10" film critic lists for the year. Every year, I note this list to keep track of what I've seen and to provide my own tiered rankings of the films. I might add some comments especially if I've updated my rankings from my prior post on new films that I managed to see in 2021.
Generally, I post this list in February (just to be sure the rankings are final) and I'll have typically seen about half of them -- thanks partly to a concerted effort in the new year to see them.
Because we include some foreign publications, it is possible for a few titles to repeat from last year's list due to differences in USA and overseas release dates.
I have seen a few of these films to-date, but have plenty to go (22 of 30 listed). As I watch them, I'll highlight changes.
Tier 1 These are top-notch Oscar-worthy films.
Belfast
The Worst Person in the World
The Power of the Dog
Summer of Soul
Licorice Pizza
Passing
Obviously, I would have selected Belfast over CODA for Best Picture. Summer of Soul was really entertaining and Licorice Pizza was fun. See The Worst Person in the World.
C'mon C'mon
Red Rocket
The French Dispatch
The Lost Daughter
CODA
The Card Counter
Pig (Hulu)
Dune (HBO Max)
The Mitchells vs. The Machines (Netflix)
Flee (Hulu)
Spencer
The Tragedy of Macbeth
Drive My Car
C'mon C'mon features a terrific kid actor and a solid performance by Joaquin Phoenix. And a Gaby Hoffman sighting.
Red Rocket director Sean Baker makes really good films -- this one is about someone from the Boogie Nights porn scene returning to Texas in unexplained poverty. Bad decisions prevail, but character choices are limited by their context.
The Card Counter turned out to be an Iraq film, which I didn't realize before viewing it. It's difficult to watch at times. Viewers likely expect to see a gambler succeeding (or failing) with life-altering consequences. Here, you get that, but also Abu Ghraib flashbacks.
Frankly, the order of the first 6 of these Tier 2 films could be altered on any given day.
Tier 3 These are likely good films, but with more flaws.
The Souvenir Part II
The Green Knight
None so far.
I typically don't need lower tiers for this list because it is comprised of the very best movies of the year -- at least according to film critics.
Here's the alphabetical list of the 22 films that I have not yet seen (with some streaming info added):
Annette
Bad Luck Banging or Loony Porn
Memoria
Parallel Mothers
Petite Maman
tick, tick..BOOM! (Netflix)
Titane
West Side Story
Wheel of Fortune and Fantasy